Best Tequila & Margarita Bottles to Buy in Amsterdam, NY Right Now

If you walk into a liquor store in 2026 and still think tequila is just for salt-rimmed shots that you’ll regret by morning, it’s time for an update. The "Agave Boom" has officially hit Montgomery County, and the shelves at Black Bear Wine & Spirits are looking better than ever.

Whether you are looking for a clean, citrusy Blanco for a backyard barbecue or a velvety Reposado for slow sipping, the options in Amsterdam have evolved. You don't have to settle for the "bottom shelf" anymore. Here is the lowdown on the best bottles you can grab right now to elevate your margarita game or your bar cart.

The All-Stars: Top Tequila Picks

1. LALO Blanco (The Purest Pour)

If you haven't tried LALO yet, you’re missing out on what many are calling the cleanest tequila on the market this year. It’s a Blanco in its purest form—no additives, no wood, just agave, yeast, and water. It’s bright, it’s peppery, and it makes a Margarita taste like actual fruit rather than a sugar bomb.

• Best for: The "Skinny" Margarita or sipping on the rocks with a twist of lime.

2. Espolon Reposado (The Reliable Workhorse)

For those who want a bit of "soul" in their tequila without spending a fortune, Espolon Reposado is the gold standard. Aged in American oak, it carries hints of ginger and vanilla that play incredibly well with spicy mixers.

• Best for: Spicy Jalapeño Margaritas or a Tequila Old Fashioned.

3. 1800 Tequila Blanco (The Crowd Pleaser)

You can’t go wrong with the classic. 1800 Blanco is smooth, consistent, and looks great on a bar top. It’s the kind of bottle you buy when you’re hosting a group and you know everyone will be happy with the results.

• Best for: Large batches of frozen Margaritas for a summer party.

Shop Amsterdam’s Best Tequila Selection →

The "Cheat Code": Ready-to-Drink & Mixers

Look, we get it. Sometimes you don't want to be the chemist behind the bar. You just want a drink that hits right the second you pour it over ice.

• Jose Cuervo Authentic Margaritas: These are the ultimate "grab and go." Whether it’s the Classic Lime or the Strawberry, these 1.75L bottles are designed for convenience. Just add ice, salt the rim if you’re feeling fancy, and you are done.
• On The Rocks (OTR) Hornitos Margarita: If you want a "bar-quality" cocktail in a bottle, OTR is the move. It uses real Hornitos Tequila and is perfectly balanced. It’s small, portable, and surprisingly potent.
• Zing Zang Mango Margarita Mix: If you already have the tequila but want a tropical twist, this mix is a game-changer. It uses real mango puree and lime—none of that neon-colored syrup that gives you a headache.

Why Shop Local at Black Bear Wine & Spirits?

We know you have choices in Amsterdam, but Black Bear Wine & Spirits on Route 30 is more than just a place to buy a bottle. We’ve curated a selection specifically for the Montgomery County palate.

Plus, we make it ridiculously easy to get what you need:

• 1-Hour Delivery: Hosting a party and realize you're out of lime juice and tequila? Don't leave your guests. We’ll bring it to your door.
• Curbside Pickup: In a rush? Order online and we’ll run it out to your car. No need to unbuckle the kids or deal with the rain.
• Expert Advice: Not sure about the difference between a Highland and Lowland agave? Just ask. Our team actually knows their stuff.

Pro Tip for the Perfect Amsterdam Margarita

Don't ruin a great bottle of tequila with cheap ice. If you're making a high-end marg, use large, clear ice cubes. They melt slower, meaning your drink stays cold without turning into a watery mess while you're hanging out on the patio.

Browse Premium Margarita Mixers & RTDs →

Ready to stock up? Swing by Black Bear Wine & Spirits today or browse our full tequila and mixer inventory online. Your next Friday night deserves a better drink.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Blanco, Reposado, and Añejo?

Think of it as a timeline. Blanco is unaged and tastes most like the agave plant—bright and citrusy. Reposado is "rested" in oak barrels for 2 to 12 months, picking up a gold color and smooth vanilla notes. Añejo is aged for over a year, making it dark, rich, and more like a fine whiskey or cognac.

Do I really need to buy expensive tequila for Margaritas?

Not necessarily, but you should look for "100% De Agave" on the label. "Mixto" tequilas (which use added sugars) are usually what lead to that rough next-day feeling. A mid-range bottle like Espolon or Lunazul is perfect for mixing without breaking the bank.

Can I get tequila delivered in Amsterdam?

Yes! We offer 1-hour delivery within the Amsterdam and Perth area. Just place your order through our website, and we’ll handle the rest. Make sure you have your ID ready!

What is the best way to store my tequila once it's open?

Unlike wine, tequila won't go bad once opened, but it can oxidize over a long period. Keep it in a cool, dark place (away from the Amsterdam summer sun) and make sure the cap is on tight. Don't worry about the fridge unless you prefer it chilled for shots.

Do you carry salt and mixers too?

Absolutely. We are a one-stop shop. From Tajín and Margarita salt to premium mixers like Tres Agaves and Zing Zang, we have everything you need to build the perfect cocktail from scratch.